Our Evaluation Methodology

To bring you the best mystery box shopping experience, we understand that you need reliable and accurate recommendations. That’s why we have carefully selected and tested each website against several criteria to ensure that you can find the perfect mystery box for you.


Our top criteria include prize value, website security and reliability, and overall user experience. We provide examples of what scoring high and low on each criterion looks like. Additionally, we take into consideration promotions and discounts, shipping and delivery, payment options, and customer support.


Our evaluation process aims to give you a better understanding of the websites and their strengths and weaknesses. We want you to feel confident that the mystery box you receive is worth the cost and provides a positive shopping experience.



By using our criteria to evaluate each website, we aim to provide you with the most comprehensive and helpful information to make your mystery box shopping experience stress-free and enjoyable!

Our TOP Criteria:


Prize Value

Considers whether the prizes included in the mystery box are worth the cost of the box.

High Prize Value

A mystery box costs $50 and contains prizes worth at least $50, such as a high-quality pair of headphones or a popular video game.

Low Prize Value

A mystery box costs $50 and contains prizes that are only worth $30, such as a low-quality phone case and a cheap set of earbuds.


Website Security & Reliability

Examines the security and reliability of the website, including the protection of customer information and the availability of reliable customer support.

Strong Security & Reliability

The website provides secure payment options, such as SSL encryption, and has reliable customer support that responds to customer inquiries within a reasonable time frame.

Weak Security & Reliability

The website does not provide secure payment options and has poor customer support, with long wait times and unresponsive representatives.


Overall User Experience

Considers the ease of use and user-friendliness of the website, providing a positive and enjoyable shopping experience for customers.

Good User Experience

The website is easy to navigate, with clear product descriptions and high-quality images. The checkout process is streamlined and hassle-free.

Poor User Experience

The website is difficult to navigate, with confusing product descriptions and low-quality images. The checkout process is complicated and frustrating.

Secondary Criteria:


Promotions & Discounts

Considers the regularity and availability of promotions and discounts to encourage customer purchases.

Ample Promotions & Discounts:

The website offers regular promotions and discounts, such as a 10% off coupon for new customers or a buy one, get one free deal.

Limited Promotions & Discounts:

The website rarely offers promotions or discounts, and the ones that are available are not significant or worthwhile.


Shipping & Delivery

Examines the speed and reliability of shipping options offered by the site, including the availability of tracking information to ensure timely and secure delivery.

Efficient Shipping & Delivery:

The website offers fast and reliable shipping, with tracking information provided to customers so they can monitor the status of their shipment.

Poor Shipping & Delivery:

The website has slow and unreliable shipping, with no tracking information provided to customers, leading to lost or delayed shipments.


Payment Options

Considers the variety of payment options available to customers, ensuring that customers can easily use their preferred payment method.

Diverse Payment Options:

The website offers a variety of payment options, such as credit card, PayPal, and Apple Pay, to accommodate different customer preferences.

Limited Payment Options:

The website only offers one payment option, such as credit card, which may not be convenient or accessible for all customers.


Customer Support

Examines the availability and quality of customer support, including response time and issue resolution, to ensure that customers can receive assistance when needed.

Great Customer Support:

The website provides prompt and helpful customer support, with representatives available via phone, email, or live chat to assist with any issues or concerns.

Poor Customer Support:

The website has poor customer support, with representatives who are unresponsive or unhelpful, leading to frustrated customers and unresolved issues.